The Potential for Ducted Wind Turbines in an Urban Environment

Introduction

Rising incomes and an additional 1.7 billion people mostly added to urban areas in developing countries will push up global energy demand by 25% in the period to 2040 [1]. The convergence of affordable and reliable renewable energy technologies with effective policy implementation at the international and national levels is set to push societies closer towards meeting many of the world's sustainable development goals. While cost-effective renewable energy technologies enable community-based models of energy production, shifting supply and demand calls for continuous improvement in energy efficiency across both private and public sectors. In order for wind technology to be a viable contender, next-generation wind turbines should increase both performance and reliability, thus lowering the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE). Wind power accounted for 4.2% of the total energy generated in 2017 and is expected to account for a quarter of all energy generation by 2040 [1].

The share of wind energy in global energy supply underscores the need for affordable, reliable and scalable wind energy systems. A vast majority of wind energy production today is from offshore and onshore wind turbines located far away from urban areas which account for 70% of the global electricity demand [2]. As the demand for energy from urban areas increases, the interplay between the production and consumption of electricity has a key role to play in the reliability of wind energy systems. To account for this increase in electricity demand, the prospect of urban energy production has been explored [3,4,5,6]. Energy production in urban areas will help reduce transmission losses and significantly lower the cost of distribution infrastructure [7]. Moreover, localized energy production will also help increase the global energy intensity, a key aspect towards attaining the Sustainable Development Goals. The integration of wind energy production with the urban landscape presents a number of challenges. Firstly, the mean velocity of wind currents is reduced due to surface roughness, topography, and proximity to buildings and trees [8]. The increase in turbulence also causes rapid fluctuations in the direction of the wind [9]. Secondly, the limited availability of space imposes a constraint on the size of the wind turbine. Lastly, an urban environment necessitates the use of simple and ergonomic design; large wind turbines have complex yaw drive mechanisms to align the rotor to the wind and thus such systems cannot be integrated into an urban landscape. The need for an efficient, compact and decentralized wind energy system has put Ducted Wind Turbines (DWTs) at the forefront of innovation efforts.

The first theoretical analysis of DWTs can be found in the pioneering work of Lilley and Rainbird in 1956 [11]. Subsequently, a number of researchers carried out experimental studies on the augmentation of DWTs in the seventies; Foreman et al [12] investigated the use of boundary layer controlled diffusion for enhancing the augmentation imparted by a duct. The formative work of Igra [13] concluded that the performance of a DWT was far superior as compared to a bare wind turbine of the same diameter. He also developed a one-dimensional analytical model which constituted the basis for many future works. Van Bussel [14] found that the power extracted by a DWT can exceed the Betz limit by a factor of 2.5. Aranake and Duraisamy [15] analyzed the performance of DWT at low wind speeds and found that the augmentation imparted by the duct on the flow aids the DWT in harnessing electricity even in low wind speed environments. Creswell et al [16] investigated the effect of flow yaw on the power coefficient of the DWT. The study concluded that DWT show increased performance even when the incoming flow is not aligned perpendicular to the rotor plane. This characteristic property of DWT enables them to be used in urban environments where the direction of the wind does not remain constant for prolonged periods. In addition to the aforementioned literature on DWT, a number of studies were conducted based on analytical, numerical and experimental methods over the course of almost forty years [17,18,19,20,21,22,23]. These studies show that a greater amount of power can be generated by using DWTs as opposed to bare rotors. Moreover, aeroacoustic analyses conducted by the number of researchers [24,25] determined that the quiet operation of ducted systems as opposed to bare rotors makes it a viable technology for energy production in urban environments.

Discussion

The interdependence of distribution and consumption highlights yet another key aspect in the growing energy network of the world: electricity access. The engineering and economic aspect of energy distribution in developing countries have been addressed by a number of high-quality studies. While both techno-economic, as well as socio-political aspects of mini-grids and electricity access, have been discussed, there is no specific literature paving the way for DWT to be considered as a potential technology for decentralized energy production.

As analyzed by a number of researchers, the constraints posed by the urban environment are easily overcome by DWTs; reduced wind speed due to the influence of the atmospheric boundary layer is recoupled by an increased mass flow rate through the rotor plane. Due to this increased mass flow rate, DWT can produce more power per unit area of rotor leading to lesser space utilization as compared to conventional HAWTs for the same output power and lastly, the performance of a DWT is not impacted by turbulent fluctuations leading to changes in wind direction or yaw angle. DWT's have the potential to reduce the power acquired from centralized power generators and pave the way towards sustainable cities. By reducing the dependence of urban households and industries on centralized power grids, DWTs presents a new way of sourcing energy at a local level, aiding community-based models of energy distribution and consumption.

Picture courtesy: GreentechLead

References

1. IEA, World Energy Outlook 2018, International Energy Agency, 2019.
2. UNDESA, World Urbanization Prospects The 2018 Revision, UNDESA, 1st edition, 2018.
3. D. M. Kammen, D. A. Sunter, City-integrated renewable energy for urban sustainability, Science 352 (2016) 922–928.
4. F. Creutzig, G. Baiocchi, R. Bierkandt, P.-P. Pichler, K. C. Seto, Global typology of urban energy use and potentials for an urbanization mitigation wedge, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 112 (2015) 6283–6288.
5. Sharifi, Y. Yamagata, Principles and criteria for assessing urban energy resilience: A literature review, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 60 (2016) 1654–1677.
6. S. Teske, T. Pregger, S. Simon, T. Naegler, High renewable energy penetration scenarios and their implications for urban energy and transport systems, Current opinion in environmental sustainability 30 (2018) 89– 102.
7. S. Stankovic, N. Campbell, A. Harries, Urban wind energy, Routledge, 2009. 4
8. E. Ng, C. Yuan, L. Chen, C. Ren, J. C. Fung, Improving the wind environment in high-density cities by understanding urban morphology and surface roughness: a study in hong kong, Landscape and Urban planning 101 (2011) 59–74.
9. Abohela, N. Hamza, S. Dudek, Effect of roof shape, wind direction, building height and urban configuration on the energy yield and positioning of roof mounted wind turbines, Renewable Energy 50 (2013) 1106–1118.
10. R. Bontempo, M. Manna, Effects of the duct thrust on the performance of ducted wind turbines, Energy 99 (2016) 274–287.
11. G. Lilley, W. Rainbird, A preliminary report on the design and performance of ducted windmills, Technical Report, College of Aeronautics Cranfield, 1956.
12. K. Foreman, B. Gilbert, R. Oman, Diffuser augmentation of wind turbines, Solar Energy 20 (1978) 305–311.
13. O. Igra, Research and development for shrouded wind turbines, Energy Conversion and Management 21 (1981) 13–48.
14. G. J. Van Bussel, The science of making more torque from wind: Diffuser experiments and theory revisited., in: Journal of Physics: Conference Series, volume 75, IOP Publishing, p. 012010.
15. A. Aranake, K. Duraisamy, Aerodynamic optimization of shrouded wind turbines, Wind Energy 20 (2017) 877–889.
16. N. Cresswell, G. Ingram, R. Dominy, The impact of diffuser augmentation on a tidal stream turbine, Ocean Engineering 108 (2015) 155–163.
17. V. Dighe, F. Avallone, G. van Bussel, Computational study of diffuser augmented wind turbine using actuator disc force method, International Journal of Computational Methods and Experimental Measurements 4 (2016) 522–531.
18. V. V. Dighe, F. Avallone, J. Tang, G. van Bussel, Effects of gurney flaps on the performance of diffuser augmented wind turbine, in: 35th Wind Energy Symposium, p. 1382. 5
19. D. Suri, Design of an optimized inlet shroud for a flanged diffuser (2019).
20. R. Bontempo, M. Manna, Effects of the approximations embodied in the momentum theory as applied to the nrel phase vi wind turbine, International Journal of Turbomachinery, Propulsion and Power 2 (2017) 9.
21. Y. Ohya, T. Karasudani, A. Sakurai, K.-i. Abe, M. Inoue, Development of a shrouded wind turbine with a flanged diffuser, Journal of wind engineering and industrial aerodynamics 96 (2008) 524–539.
22. T. Khamlaj, M. Rumpfkeil, Theoretical analysis of shrouded horizontal axis wind turbines, Energies 10 (2017) 38.
23. J. Radhakrishnan, D. Suri, Design and optimisation of a low reynolds number airfoil for small horizontal axis wind turbines, IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering 377 (2018) 012053.
24. Hashem, M. Mohamed, A. A. Hafiz, Aero-acoustics noise assessment for wind-lens turbine, Energy 118 (2017) 345–368.
25. D. Heimann, Y. K¨asler, G. Gross, The wake of a wind turbine and its influence on sound propagation, Meteorologische Zeitschrift 20 (2011) 449–460.